| 10.11.1894 | Rotherham Town | 3 | - | 2 | W | 4.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | Bob Donaldson, William Davidson, James Peters | |||||
| 12.01.1895 | Rotherham Town | 1 | - | 2 | L | 2.000 | LgDiv2 | U | Millmoor | Fred Erentz | |||||
| 11.01.1896 | Rotherham Town | 3 | - | 0 | W | 3.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | Bob Donaldson x2, R.Stephenson | |||||
| 07.03.1896 | Rotherham Town | 3 | - | 2 | W | 1.500 | LgDiv2 | U | Millmoor | William Kennedy, Bob Donaldson, Richard Smith | |||||
| 02.12.1922 | Rotherham United | 3 | - | 0 | W | 13.500 | LgDiv2 | H | Old Trafford | Arthur Lochhead, Neil McBain, Joe Spence | |||||
| 09.12.1922 | Rotherham United | 1 | - | 1 | D | 7.500 | LgDiv2 | U | Millmoor | Ernest Goldthorpe | |||||
| 12.02.1966 | Rotherham United | 0 | - | 0 | D | 54.263 | FACup | R4 | H | Old Trafford | |||||
| 15.02.1966 | Rotherham United | 1 | - | 0 | W | 23.500 | FACup | R4rp | aet | U | Millmoor | John Connelly 115' | |||
| 28.09.1988 | Rotherham United | 1 | - | 0 | W | 12.588 | LCup | R2-1 | U | Millmoor | Peter Davenport 60' | ||||
| 12.10.1988 | Rotherham United | 5 | - | 0 | W | 20.597 | LCup | R2-2 | H | Old Trafford | Brian McClair 27', 29', 69', Bryan Robson 35', Steve Bruce 48' |